Sensemaking is therefore never decoupled from the language, institutional routines or imagined expectations of others. The first two of these are theories from different domains. Sensemaking in institutional change pdf,, download ebookee alternative reliable tips for a much healthier ebook reading. Before completing a doctorate that really anchored my work in ethnography, i was trained as a cognitive psychologist, designing and evaluating user. A case study of organizational sensemaking scott a. Sensemaking theory the sensemaking theory consists of both the interpretation of information and generating what is interpreted. Cq press your definitive resource for politics, policy and people. In simpler terms, the process by which people give meaning to experiences. Sensemaking sensemaking is the process by which people give meaningtoexperience. Lessons from two cases the analytic power of sensemaking has been widely applied throughout the organizational literature. The purpose of this paper is to explore the mental models of top executive team members in a selected retail bank. Sensemaking of a sustainability transition by higher.
Institutional theory provides powerful tools for understanding the comiiplicated relationship between schools and their multifaceted environment. Specifically, we use sensemaking and institutional logics theory as a lens through which to consider and draw insight from the events of ct2. We explore how organizational members made sense of these strategic. Whilethisprocesshasbeenstud iedbyotherdisciplinesunderothernamesforcenturies, theterm sensemakinghasprimarilymarkedthreedis tinctbutrelatedresearchareassincethe1970s. An implicit purpose of the paper is to deliberate on how sensemaking theory could be used as an instrument for empirical research. Hence, strategic change, such as st, must be accompanied by a significant alteration of the overall perception of the organisation gioia and thomas, 1996. This chapter outlines ten steps to effective sensemaking, grouped under enabling leaders to explore the wider system, create a map of that system, and act in the. Sage books the ultimate social sciences digital library. However, it does not explicitly account for how organisational actors make sense of and enact technologies in their local context. Gary klein and his colleagues have laid out a theory of sensemaking that might be useful for intelligent systems applications. Institutional theory has proven to be a central analytical perspective for investigating the role of social and historical structures of information systems is implementation.
We use sensemaking theory to explore the role of bureaucratic entrepreneurial action in institutional change. Yet, one persistent criticism levelled at his work has been a neglect of the role of larger social and historical contexts in sensemaking. Institutional th eories as applied t o politics posit two distinct f orms of in stitutions influen ce over policy and political action. Weick in the 1970s and has affected both theory and practice. Bringing theories and tools together nikhil sharma school of information, university of michigan, ann arbor address. The concept was introduced to organizational studies by karl e. Sense makingwasintroducedtohumancomputerinteraction byparcresearchersrussell,ste. First, consideration of the tenets of existing theory in light of new phenomena can offer rich insight into the boundary conditions and contingency factors associated. Pawlowski creighton university this paper provides an example of how institutional servicelearning assessment data can be used to drive organizational change. Its worth reading just for the preface, which is delightfully welcoming for a volume of organizational theory. All these concepts are associated with the process of making art and its role in society as a process that essentially helps us make sense of life and our experiences on an abstract and. I believe the gap is the absence, the void, and the alienation where truthmeaningsense should be. We elaborate this analytic model by examining a major institutional change. Sensemaking in organisations towards a conceptual framework for understanding strategic change thomas ericson jonkokping international business school, kyrkogatan 15, p.
Sensemaking or sensemaking is the process by which people give meaning to their collective experiences. Metaphors from music composition illustrate the pace and depth of institutional change. In this paper we take the position that the concept of sensemaking fills important gaps in organizational theory. Building on this, we discuss how organizational identity research might benefit from closer. The leading scholar in this area has been karl weick, who began writing about sensemaking in the late 1960s. Organizing and the process of sensemaking organization. A generic institutional model for analyzing and managing hazards, disasters and crises worldwide.
It emphasizes how norms and cultural conceptions about appropriate reading instruction are constructed and reconstructed over timne. Pdf using institutional theory with sensemaking theory. It illustrates how rigidity, leader dependence, and erratic behavior get in the way of effective sensemaking, and how one might teach sensemaking as a core leadership capability. Sensemaking enables leaders to have a better grasp of what is going on in their environments, thus facilitating other leadership activities such as visioning, relating, and inventing. Download sources of national institutional competitiveness. In recent years, institutional theorists have been increasingly interested in institutional change, seeking to understand the contextual factors and agents responsible for alterations to existing institutional arrangements. Although retrospective sensemaking is a key property of the weickian approach, sensemaking can also orient to the future.
Bureaucratic entrepreneurship and institutional change. According to berthod 2016, the institutional theory of organizations puts institutions at the forefront of the analysis of organizations design and conduct. This theoretical distance may be related to criticisms of sensemaking that claim the theory overlooks the role of larger social, historical or institutional contexts in explaining cognition. Whilethisprocesshasbeenstudiedbyotherdisciplinesunderothernamesforcenturies. Resilience, sensemaking and internal crisis communication. Sensemaking is the process by which people construct, interpret, and recognize meaningful features of the world. The paradox of sensemaking in organizational analysis. Professor joop koppenjan, erasmus university rotterdam, the netherlands this book has done an excellent job in opening the black box of how organizations make sense of the crisis situations they face and develop strategies to respond. This book provides not only a theory of crisis management but also a key concept around which research and practice can be conducted. This article examines the explicit and implicit corporate social responsibility csr framework and its implications for leadership style, in a major banking institution. Assessing institutional support for servicelearning. Institutional theory in political science has made great advances in recent years, but also has a number of significant theoretical and methodological problems.
Managing uncertainty in crisis exploring the impact of. Sage video bringing teaching, learning and research to life. While there is no single theory of sensemaking, many researchers use the concept to study how people understand i. Using institutional theory with sensemaking theory. This chapter seeks to relate sensemaking and sensegiving processes to their social and institutional context by describing and explaining the effects of diverse metaphors of change used by organizational members during the implementation of lean production and tqm in an internationally operating manufacturing company. The most important of these problems is the generally static nature of institutional explanations. Decoupling between policy and practice through the lens of sensemaking and sensegiving. A case study of information system implementation in healthcare article pdf available in journal of information technology 244.
Ecological sensemaking academy of management journal. We begin by examining the different ways that organizational identity has been conceptualized and explain the evolving theoretical interests that lie behind the approaches that have been taken. Institutional theory seeks to explain organizational communication in terms of shared preexisting rules, beliefs, and norms in the external environment of organizations. Karl weicks sensemaking perspective has proven to be a central influence on process theories of organizing. The interplay between theorization, representation, and ongoing event attention can lead to change in institutional logics over an events life course. In addition to theorization, highlighted by prior research, we propose a second mechanism of environmental sensemaking. Weick the teaching of organization theory and the conduct of organizational research have been dominated by a focus on decisionmaking and the concept of. Event attention, environmental sensemaking, and change in. Professor naim kapucu, director of school of public administration, university of central florida, usa. We then reanalyze data from the mann gulch fire and conclude that ecological. Evidence for existence of the frameworks key concepts in relation to leadership styles was explored through the selfreported sensemaking of leaders charged with csr programme introduction.
Sensemaking is central because it is the primary site where meanings materialize that inform and constrain identity and action. In this tradition, we present an ethnographic tale from the subarctic to introduce the concept of ecological sensemakingthe process used to make sense of material landscapes and ecological processes. While its sociological origins rest on the concepts of legitimacy, rational myths, and isomorphic forces in organizational fields. The focus is on how each executive team member makes sense of the market situation and changes with regard to customers and customerbank interactions in the current situation where earlier bank practices are at risk of becoming obsolete. A powerful example of institutional effects on sensemaking in crisis is provided by wicks 2002 study of the 1992 westray mine disaster, in which he explores how institutional and organizational logics over time affected organizational members sensemaking in ways that led them to overlook important cues. At root, institutional theory is a cultural approach. Yet, while weicks 1993 seminal article on the collapse of sensemaking in organizations has been widely cited in the educational literature, it has rarely been applied to the problem of. Sensemaking in organizations consists of a preface and eight chapters that set out the origins, principles, and applications of weicks sensemaking concepts. This chapter explores the social processes and practices of future. Karl weicks classic study of sensemaking showed that there is much to be learned from a wildland fire. Sensemaking, a concept first popularized by karl weick, is a heuristic involving seven social psychological properties that can be used to understand how people make sense of the process of organizing. Sensemaking offers a way of understanding the process by which.
Organizing and the process of sensemaking article pdf available in organization science 164. We address this critique by showing how institutional context is a necessary part of sensemaking. Weick, 1995, which, put simply, is how people think sensemaking, and how people attempt to influence how others think sensegiving. Sage reference the complete guide for your research journey. In this chapter, we explore how the concept of organizational identity has evolved in institutional theory.
877 1663 533 502 836 1347 1533 658 74 1468 461 1183 1351 361 754 870 579 192 562 905 933 798 568 709 958 983 1519 74 84 398 230 870 490 509 966 1459 1191 838 1090 1241